🏛️ Sovereign Legal Tender • Vault-Grade Preservation • 100% PCGS & NGC Eligible  🏛️ 

Welcome to our store. Learn more

Offers & Rollbacks Low prices on 100's of items

Coin Grading Explained: Understanding the Sheldon Scale

By FORTYMILLION  •   48 minute read

Obverse and reverse of a 2000 American Silver Eagle graded PCGS MS70, showing Walking Liberty and a heraldic eagle with shield.

PCGS MS70
PCGS #: 9949
Designer: Adolph A. Weinman/John Mercanti
Edge: Reeded
Diameter: 40.60 millimeters
Weight: 31.10 grams
Mintage: 9,239,132
Mint: Philadelphia
Metal: 99.93% Silver, .007% Copper*
Auction Record: $33,275 • MS70 • 05-05-2013 • Great Collections

*The composition above is reproduced from PCGS CoinFacts. The U.S. Mint lists the American Eagle Silver Bullion coin’s composition as 99.9% silver.

Photos and coin information: PCGS CoinFacts — 2000 American Silver Eagle (PCGS #9949).

Coin Grading Explained: Understanding the Sheldon Scale

A coin’s grade can tell you a great deal about its condition, but it cannot tell you everything.

The grading number on a certification label needs to be read alongside the method of manufacture, surface designations and any qualifications.

Not every grading system uses a number, however. Traditional adjectival grading describes a coin’s condition with words such as Fine, Very Fine, Extremely Fine and Uncirculated, usually abbreviated to F, VF, EF and UNC.

This assessment considers wear, the sharpness of the original strike, contact marks, remaining mint lustre or bloom, and overall visual appeal. Missing detail caused by a weak strike must not be mistaken for wear. Uncirculated coins can also differ considerably in quality: although they show no wear, their strike, surface marks and remaining lustre can distinguish an ordinary Uncirculated example from a Choice or Gem Uncirculated coin.

The following table summarises the major labels in the Australasian Numismatic Dealers’ Association’s guide to grading Australian Commonwealth coins. These descriptions are not exact equivalents to Sheldon numerical grades.

Australian Commonwealth Coin Grades — ANDA Adjectival Guide
Grade label Abbreviation Definition
Fleur de Coin FDC French for “flower of the die”. ANDA reserves this term for perfection and describes it as exceptionally rare among coins made for circulation. It describes quality, not a method of manufacture such as Proof.
Gem Uncirculated GEM or Gem-Unc An unworn, near-perfect coin with an almost perfect strike and virtually full mint lustre or bloom. Only a few minute surface marks may be present, barely visible to the naked eye.
Choice Uncirculated CHU or Ch-Unc An unworn, well-struck coin, although minor detail may be missing from the highest points because of the strike. A scattering of insignificant contact marks may be present. At least moderate mint lustre or bloom remains, with very pleasing overall visual appeal.
Uncirculated UNC No wear is present. Some weakness of strike and a small number of moderate contact marks may be evident. Some mint lustre or bloom remains, although it may be subdued. Excessive marks or striking weaknesses should be described separately.
Almost Uncirculated aUNC Close to Uncirculated, but with faint traces of wear on the highest points of the design. Some original mint lustre usually remains, particularly in protected areas around the lettering. An attractive appearance does not cancel out the presence of wear.
Extremely Fine EF Light wear is visible on the highest points of the design on both sides. Small surface marks may be evident. Traces of original mint lustre may survive in protected areas around the lettering.
Very Fine VF Moderate wear has flattened the highest points of the design, while substantial detail remains. Contact marks and minor edge nicks may be present; excessive marks should be disclosed separately.
Fine F Extensive wear affects the design, although its main outlines remain distinct and raised. Much of the finer detail has disappeared. Numerous marks may be present, but prominent gouges or scratches should not be treated as ordinary wear.
Very Good VG Heavy wear has removed much of the raised detail, leaving the principal design outlines. Some smaller lettering or internal details may be partly or completely worn away. Despite its name, Very Good is below Fine in this grading hierarchy.
Good G A heavily worn coin whose complete design outline remains at least faintly visible. Much of the raised detail is flat or nearly flat. Despite its name, Good is the lowest major grade listed in this ANDA guide.

Source: ANDA: Grading Commonwealth Coins. These definitions summarise the ANDA guide rather than a universal standard. Terminology and interpretation can differ between countries, dealers and references.

Intermediate descriptions refine these major grades. “Good Very Fine” (gVF) means slightly better than Very Fine, while “Almost Extremely Fine”, “About Extremely Fine” or “Near Extremely Fine” (aEF or nEF) means just below Extremely Fine. “Good Very Fine” (gVF) means the coin is slightly better than Very Fine, but not good enough to reach Extremely Fine. The word “Good” on its own names a different grade near the bottom of the scale.

A split grade describes different conditions on the two sides. For example, CHU/UNC means the obverse is Choice Uncirculated and the reverse is Uncirculated. In ANDA’s convention, the obverse grade is written first.

The Sheldon scale runs from 1, the lowest condition grade, to 70, the highest. It aims to describe a coin’s condition more precisely than broad descriptive terms alone. For coins assessed as Mint State (MS), the Uncirculated range begins at MS60 and extends to MS70. These coins show no wear. Their original mint lustre or bloom may be bright or dull: dullness describes its appearance, whereas wear involves the physical loss of the original surface. Contact marks and other imperfections can affect their grade. Coins graded below 60 show wear, with the original mint lustre or bloom diminished or missing from the worn areas. Wear can develop through everyday circulation, as coins pass through tills, wallets, banks, businesses and the general public wherever coinage is needed. Wear can also occur without a coin being spent, through repeated handling or rubbing against other surfaces during storage. In either case, friction gradually removes the original surface lustre and smooths the raised details.

 In 2026, the Sheldon 1–70 scale is the predominant framework for international third-party numerical coin grading, particularly through the grading companies  PCGS and NGC. It has not universally replaced adjectival grading, which remains in use by dealers and auction houses, including in Australia and Britain. The Sheldon scale is widely used, but it is not necessarily universal. Some grading services use different numerical scales or descriptive systems, particularly for ancient coins. Even where companies use the same scale, they apply their own grading standards. 

For coins supplied in their original mint packaging, or sold loose from mint rolls, bags and sets, FORTYMILLION uses descriptions such as Brilliant Uncirculated, ex-set or Proof rather than assigning a numerical condition grade. These broad descriptions are more practical for our listings, while numerical grading requires meticulous examination of each coin’s wear, strike, surface marks, lustre and overall appearance.

Proof coins are supplied as taken from their mint packaging or remain encapsulated from the mint. For premium-priced Proof coins, we provide photographs of the actual coins offered. Our condition assessment is limited to identifying issues such as post-manufacture damage (PMD), milk spotting, corrosion or other visible surface deterioration. Original packaging should not be taken as a guarantee of a flawless coin. We leave numerical grading to independent specialist services such as PCGS and NGC, keeping the seller’s description separate from an independent grading opinion. These services assess condition against published standards and, where appropriate, assign a numerical grade. A coin does not have to be flawless to receive a high grade, nor does it need a numerical grade to be flawless. Many raw coins sold by FORTYMILLION  have subsequently received a grade of 70 from independent grading services.

The following table shows how different imperfections can affect grading.

Coin Imperfections and Their Effect on Grading
Type[1] Description Grade usually given[1]
Adjustment Marks These include mostly early coins, excess metal (such as silver and gold) was cut from overweight coins to conform to weight laws.[2] MS66 and lower
Planchet defects Lamination defects are caused by flaws in a coin's metal before it was struck. Some "established planchet defects on early copper" may be more readily accepted by grading services.[3] MS65 and lower
Die cracks A crack in the striking die allows metal to flow into it during striking, leaving a raised line on the coin. It is a mint-made feature, not post-mint damage. Does not automatically lower the grade; strike, surfaces and eye appeal remain relevant.
Striking defects Striking defects arise when the dies impress the design onto the blank. Examples include an off-centre strike or incomplete design detail caused by a weak strike. Their significance depends on the nature and severity of the defect. Mint-made defects can affect the assigned grade depending on their severity and visual impact.[4] MS64 and lower.
Unattractive toning Depending on conditions. Coins that have very low eye appeal will be affected as the market value of these coins cannot warrant a higher grade.[5] MS64 and lower
Carbon streaks Carbon streaks are a flaw caused by environmental conditions. Some contributing factors include coin storage in a damp place, or exposure to cigar or cigarette smoke.[6] MS64 and lower
Fingermarks Oils exist in human fingerprints which can leave marks on the surface of a coin. These marks are usually the result of mishandling.[7] MS63 and lower
PVC damage Improperly stored coins in vinyl 2x2 flips, older albums, and coin holders. Green and gray streaks and/or spots appear on the surface of an affected coin.[8] MS63 and lower
Black spots Also known as sulfur spots, these coins are given dark brown to black spots by sulfur in the environment. These black spots have also been incorrectly dubbed as carbon spots, but carbon does not contribute to oxidation.[9] MS63 and lower
Slide marks
(aka "rub")
Slide marks are caused by improperly placing a coin into an album that contains plastic strip slides. The marks are given as the plastic slides or rubs across the surface of a given coin.[10] MS63 and lower
Overdipping These coins were dipped into a dilute acid solution too many times which stripped the coin's surface of luster.[11] MS62 and lower
Cleaning marks

Methods mentioned include abrasives (baking soda, scouring powder and pencil erasers), brushing, burnishing or polishing, acid dipping, soap and water, olive oil, potassium cyanide, ultrasonic cleaning, vinegar and salt, and whizzing with a rotary wire brush. These are descriptions of methods used, not recommendations; cleaning can permanently damage coins. Potassium cyanide is extremely poisonous

See: Cleaning (coinage)

This link takes you to Wikipedia.

MS62 and lower
Corrosion spots Copper coins can turn green, while silver coins turn black from oxidation. MS62 and lower
Wear By definition an uncirculated coin will show no trace of wear. AU58 and lower
Whizzing These coins were gone over with a metal or wire brush to "enhance" the uncirculated details. Whizzing causes damage and wear to the surface of a coin which lowers its grade to "circulated" status.[1][12] AU50 and lower

The grades shown are general guidance, not guaranteed outcomes. Depending on their nature and severity, improper cleaning, PVC damage, corrosion or whizzing may prevent a numerical grade and result in a Details assessment instead.

Table adapted from “Sheldon coin grading scale”, Wikipedia contributors. Columns reordered and reference numbers renumbered for this article; source references are listed in the footnotes below.

Die Cracks and Other Mint-Made Features

A die crack is a fissure in the striking die, not in the coin blank. During striking, metal flows into the crack, producing a raised line or ridge on the coin. If a piece of the die breaks away, metal fills the resulting void and forms a raised area lacking design detail. These features are commonly described as cuds, interior die breaks or die chips, depending on their location and extent, although terminology varies between references and grading services. They are mint-made features, not scratches acquired afterwards. Some attract specialist interest, but their presence does not automatically make a coin rare or valuable. 

A die crack does not automatically lower a coin’s numerical grade. The coin is still assessed for surface preservation, strike, lustre and eye appeal, and a small die crack can coexist with a high Mint State grade. We will explain these terms and other coin terminology in greater detail in a future article. The important distinction is that not every apparent imperfection lowers a coin’s grade or value. Some are features of manufacture rather than damage acquired afterwards.

A Brief History of the Sheldon Scale

The Sheldon 70-point grading scale takes its name from Dr William H. Sheldon, who introduced it in his 1949 book, Early American Cents[19]. It was originally devised to relate the condition of early United States large cents to their collector values, rather than as a universal grading system. The scale was subsequently adapted into the numerical condition-grading framework used today by services such as PCGS and NGC. Modern grades run from 1 to 70, but the numbers are not price multipliers: a coin graded 70 is not necessarily worth 70 times as much as one graded 1.

PCGS and NGC use the Sheldon numerical scale as a common grading framework, allowing a coin’s condition to be described more precisely than with broad terms such as “Fine” or “Uncirculated” alone. Each service applies its own grading standards, so the shared scale does not guarantee identical assessments. Higher numbers indicate higher assigned condition grades. Neither service uses every number from 1 to 70: below 60, grades follow selected steps, while every whole number from 60 through 70 is available for Mint State grading. This does not mean that every coin issue has received every available grade.

Across PCGS’s population reports for Australia’s eight standard decimal denominations, introduced from 1966 onward, just three MS60 entries are recorded: one in the Australian $1 series and two in the Australian $2 series. These are the 2022 $1 The Smith Family coin, the 2020 $2 75th Anniversary of the End of WWII colourised coin and the 2024 $2 Olympic Team ‘Community’ colourised coin, with one recorded at MS60 for each issue. No MS60 entries are recorded in the 1c, 2c, 5c, 10c, 20c or 50c series checked.  These figures describe PCGS certification records for those denominations, not a combined PCGS and NGC total or a measure of the coins’ rarity or value.

Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) and Numismatic Guaranty Company (NGC) are leading third-party coin grading services.  Both assess United States and world coins, encapsulating certified coins in protective slabs. Their standard numerical grading systems use the 1-to-70 Sheldon scale, although each company applies its own published standards. Even though there are differences in grading standards, PCGS and NGC are coin grading  industry heavyweights. They have substantial influence and recognition in the coin market, reflected in their international reach, use by major auction houses, published grading standards and certification guarantees. It does not mean their assessments are identical or beyond dispute.

NGC guarantees that qualifying coins encapsulated in its slabs are genuine, meaning not counterfeit, and are not graded higher than NGC’s grading standards allow. These guarantees are subject to the conditions and exclusions in its published terms, including exclusions concerning counterfeit or tampered slabs, improper storage and deterioration after encapsulation. NGC Ancients is an important exception: it encapsulates only coins it considers genuine, but guarantees the grade rather than authenticity, attribution or date. NGC Guarantee · NGC Ancients Guarantee

PCGS guarantees that qualifying United States and world coins graded and encapsulated in its slabs are genuine and that their assigned grades accord with PCGS grading standards. Coins suspected of being counterfeit or overgraded may be submitted through its Guarantee Resubmission process, with remedies subject to the published terms and PCGS’s assessment. Exclusions include counterfeit or tampered slabs, obvious clerical errors, environmental damage and deterioration after certification, such as spotting, hazing, colour changes or corrosion. The guarantee is not unconditional protection against future changes to a coin’s condition. PCGS Guarantee

Leading and Regional Coin Grading Services

While PCGS and NGC are leading international coin grading services, they are regarded as top-tier services in the United States. PCGS has traditionally been the more widely preferred service in Australia. PCGS' Hong Kong office gives Australian collectors a regional submission option, Australian auction references also document PCGS' established use: Noble Numismatics catalogued a dedicated PCGS-graded collection in Sale 124, and Roxbury’s lists recurring “PCGS Australia & Modern Issues” auctions. Other established companies serve particular countries or specialise in particular types of coins. Their recognition varies between markets.

  • United States — ANACS, ICG and CAC / CACG. Alongside PCGS and NGC, these are established American grading services. ANACS has particular expertise in mint-error and die-variety attribution. ICG provides authentication, grading and encapsulation without a membership or minimum submission requirement. CAC Grading authenticates, grades and seals coins in protective slabs, while its separate stickering service reviews eligible coins already graded by PCGS or NGC.

  • Canada — ICCS, PCGS, NGC and CCCS. International Coin Certification Service (ICCS) is an established Canadian specialist. Its reputation for “conservative grading” is discussed in the NGC discussion-board thread “ICCS Grading — Any Opinions?”  means a cautious approach to awarding higher grades: surface marks or other weaknesses may keep a coin at a lower grade rather than giving it the benefit of the doubt. . That is a description of its reputation, not proof that ICCS always assigns a lower grade than PCGS or NGC. ICCS’s own explanation of assessing marks considers their size, location, number and nature. PCGS and NGC are both internationally recognised grading services used for Canadian coins.  Canadian Coin Certification Service (CCCS) is another domestic service. ICCS and CCCS are separate companies.

  • China — PCGS, NGC and Gong Bo / GBCA. PCGS and NGC are prominent international services in the Chinese coin market. Gong Bo is an established domestic grading service for Chinese coins, including ancient coins and machine-struck issues. Recognition can depend on the type of coin and whether it is traded domestically or internationally.

  • Hong Kong. PCGS and NGC both accept coin submissions through their Hong Kong offices. PCGS provides submission routes for its Collectors Club members and authorised dealers, while NGC publishes separate Hong Kong submission instructions. These are offices serving collectors and dealers, not separate grading companies using a Hong Kong condition scale.

  • Malaysia. NGC has appointed Malaysian businesses as Official Submission Centers, including Trigometric and Kingston Collections. These businesses help collectors and dealers submit coins for authentication, grading and encapsulation. They facilitate the process; NGC assigns the grades.

  • Indonesia. NGC submissions can be arranged through Indonesian Official Submission Centers such as MabeS Collectibles Guaranty and Java Auction. These local businesses receive and help arrange submissions for certification; they do not assign NGC grades themselves.

  • United Kingdom — PCGS, NGC and London Coins Grading Service. British dealers recognise PCGS and NGC as major international services. London Coins Grading Service provides a British alternative, continuing the former CGS approach. Its 100-point grading system differs from the Sheldon 1–70 scale used for standard PCGS and NGC numerical grading.

  • Continental Europe — PCGS and NGC. Both have an established European presence. They are international options for European coin certification, but Europe comprises many national collecting markets; their presence does not establish that either is the preferred service in every country.

  • Russia — National Numismatic Register (NNR), RNGA, PCGS and NGC. NNR and RNGA are domestic grading services represented in the Russian coin market. PCGS- and NGC-certified Russian coins also trade there. The available sources establish their use, but not a reliable ranking identifying one company as Russia’s leading service.

  • Middle East. NGC serves the region through CCG Middle East’s office in Dubai, where collectors can submit coins for authentication, grading and slabbing. UAE submission agents also include Rabdan Auctions and Numisbing. These agents facilitate submissions; NGC assigns the grades. This is a verified regional route, not evidence that every Middle Eastern country uses the same service.

  • Finland. PCGS and NGC certify Finnish coins, and examples from both services appear in Finnish auction catalogues. Finnish specialists such as Holmasto also authenticate coins, assess condition and provide valuations. That dealer appraisal service is distinct from independent numerical grading and slabbing.

  • Sweden. PCGS and NGC are represented through established numismatic businesses. Schulman’s Swedish office lists itself as an NGC and PCGS recognised dealer. Its own condition descriptions are separate from grades assigned by those companies.

  • Denmark. Oslo Møntgalleri’s Danish business advertises assistance with submissions to NGC. It acts as a submission intermediary, rather than assigning NGC grades itself.

  • Norway. Coins certified by PCGS and NGC trade alongside coins assessed using the traditional Norwegian condition-grading scale. Its seven main grades, from best preserved to most worn, are 0, 0/01, 01, 1+, 1, 1− and 2. Grade 0 means uncirculated. Dealers also use intermediate grades, such as 1+/01, to describe a coin between two grades. Norwegian dealer Numisma sometimes gives a Norwegian grade alongside the numerical grade already printed on a coin’s slab. The two systems do not have exact equivalents, and the dealer’s assessment does not change the slab grade.

  • Japan — PCGS, NGC and the Japan Numismatic Dealers Association (JNDA). PCGS and NGC provide international grading and slabbing services used by Japanese collectors and dealers. JNDA provides a domestic authentication and appraisal service, issuing certificates through its examination committee. Its certificate service should be distinguished from PCGS and NGC numerical grading and slabbing.

  • Iceland — PCGS and NGC. Both services certify Icelandic coins. This establishes their use for Icelandic coinage, rather than a ranking of which service is preferred within Iceland.

  • Pacific Islands — Fiji, Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, Vanuatu, Samoa, Tonga, Tuvalu, Kiribati, Nauru, Palau, the Marshall Islands, the Federated States of Micronesia, the Cook Islands and Niue. PCGS and NGC certify Pacific Island coinage. PCGS’s Oceania Set Registry includes categories for Fiji, the Cook Islands, Kiribati, Niue, Palau, Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tuvalu and Vanuatu. NGC’s Census also records graded coins from Tonga, Nauru, the Marshall Islands and New Guinea and Papua New Guinea. These are examples of certification coverage, not evidence of a grading office in each country or of one preferred service throughout the Pacific. A country’s inclusion in this regional overview does not, by itself, establish that either company has graded its coins.

  • South America. PCGS and NGC certify South American coinage. In Colombia, NGC appointed Numiscol in Bogotá as an Official Submission Center, helping collectors submit coins for certification. Numiscol facilitates submissions; it is not the company assigning NGC grades. This does not establish a single preferred grader across South America.

  • Africa. NGC and PCGS are recognised international grading services used in South Africa. A domestic alternative is the South African Numismatic Grading Service (SANGS), which authenticates, grades and seals coins in protective slabs. SANGS uses the Sheldon 1–70 scale, while applying its own grading standards. These services should not be presented as a single agreed ranking across Africa, where collecting markets differ between countries.

What Shapes Market Confidence

  • Auction house practices. The slabs recognised by auction houses and specialist review services help shape market confidence. For example, Stack’s Bowers’ Collectible Market Qualified (CMQ) service reviews PCGS-, NGC- and CAC-graded coins. This is a specific review policy, not evidence that auction houses accept only those companies: Stack’s Bowers also lists ANACS among recognised graders and auctions coins in other slabs.
  • Marketplace rules. Selling platforms set their own approved-grader requirements. eBay’s published collectible currency policy lists approved companies including PCGS, NGC, ANACS, ICG and CAC. Its list is not restricted to the four services sometimes cited in older comparisons. Platform approval is not an official tier ranking.
  • Resale liquidity and price guides. Realised prices, dealer bids and demand for particular slabs influence market perceptions. Greysheet and Bluesheet provide different pricing reference points, explained in “Coin Grades and Price Guides” below.
  • Financial guarantees. Published guarantees can strengthen confidence in a grading opinion. PCGS and NGC provide remedies for qualifying authenticity or grading claims under their respective terms, conditions and exclusions. These are not unconditional promises of compensation for every coin or every subsequent loss in value, and guarantees are not confined to companies described as Tier 1.

Coin Grading Services Compared

The table summarises services described by each grading company in the linked sources. It is an editorial comparison, not an official ranking, and makes no claim about resale premiums or market tiers.

Coin Grading Services Compared
Grader Services Service distinctions Official sources
PCGS Authentication, grading and encapsulation of United States and world coins. Offers grading, regrading, reconsideration and crossover submissions, alongside services such as variety attribution and coin photography. PCGS coin grading services
NGC Grades most United States and world coins from 1600 onward, with earlier coverage for some European issues. NGC Ancients is a separate service. NGC Ancients uses descriptive condition grades and separately evaluates strike and surfaces, rather than assigning a Sheldon numerical condition grade. NGC coins graded
NGC Ancients grading
CAC / CACG CAC Grading authenticates, grades and encapsulates coins. CAC also operates a separate verification and stickering service. Stickering reviews eligible PCGS- and NGC-graded coins. A green sticker identifies a coin CAC considers solid for the grade; a gold sticker identifies one it considers above the assigned grade. CAC services explained
ANACS Authentication and grading of United States coins, a range of world coins, mint errors and varieties. Offers both verification of a supplied variety attribution and research to identify a variety. Qualifying attributions appear on the certification label. ANACS services
ICG Authentication, grading and encapsulation of coins. At least two graders examine each coin; an additional grader resolves disagreements. Direct submissions require neither membership nor a minimum number of coins. ICG grading process
ICG submission FAQs

Which Grading System Does Each Service Use?

The Sheldon scale is widely used, but it is not universal. The comparison below distinguishes standard numerical grading from specialist services and alternative scales. Using the same numbers does not mean that companies apply identical grading standards.

Grading Systems Used by Each Service
Service Grading system and exceptions Sources
PCGS Sheldon-based 1–70 scale for standard numerical coin grading. PCGS also identifies a separate 10-point scale for Chinese ancient coins. PCGS grading standards
NGC Sheldon 1–70 scale for regular numerical grading. NGC Ancients uses descriptive condition grades with separate strike and surface assessments. NGCX uses a separate 10-point scale. NGC scale
NGC Ancients
NGCX
CAC / CACG CAC Grading uses the Sheldon 1–70 scale for numerical grades. CAC stickering is a separate review of eligible coins already graded by PCGS or NGC, not the assignment of a new numerical grade. CAC grading
CAC grading and stickering
ANACS Sheldon-based numerical grading from Poor 1 to Mint State 70. Its published grade chart distinguishes straight grades from problem or Details grades. ANACS grade chart
ANACS grading brochure
ICG Uses the Sheldon 1–70 scale for standard numerical grading. ICG also identifies Details grades and separate administrative result codes; these codes are not additional points on the grading scale. Sheldon-scale reference (secondary)
ICG grade codes
CCCS, Canada Publishes a Sheldon-style numerical grading guide, including the Mint State range MS60–MS70. The published guide specifically labels MS70 “never used”. CCCS coin-grading guide
London Coins Grading Service / former CGS, UK Uses a 100-point grading system, not the Sheldon 1–70 scale. The same numerical value therefore does not represent the same grade in the two systems. LCGS scale explained (secondary)
London Coins’ CGS grade examples
Gong Bo / GBCA, China A complete current official standard covering its different coin categories was not verified for this article. A secondary reference documents machine-struck coin grades such as MS65, AU58 and XF40, but this does not establish that every GBCA service uses the Sheldon scale. Machine-struck coin grading reference (Chinese; secondary)

Coin Grades and Price Guides

Grading describes a coin’s condition. Price guides address a different question: how coins of a particular issue, grade and certification are valued in the market.

Greysheet is a wholesale pricing reference, principally for the United States coin market. Its ‘bid’ values estimate what a dealer would pay another dealer for a properly graded, problem-free coin after having the opportunity to inspect it, known as a ‘sight-seen’ transaction. Greysheet values are not restricted to a particular grading company and can apply to appropriately graded uncertified coins.

Bluesheet provides certification-specific pricing, including separate values for PCGS- and NGC-certified coins. CDN describes these as baseline or ‘sight-unseen’ values: an indication of what the market would pay for a coin of that issue and certified grade without selecting it for superior appearance. Greysheet values generally represent stronger examples within the grade, while separate CAC pricing reflects qualifying CAC-approved coins. These are market references, not guaranteed buying or selling prices. Compare the same issue, grade, designation and visual quality before attributing a price difference to the grading company alone.

A slab alone does not establish a grading service’s independence or reliability. For an unfamiliar company, check its published standards, guarantees, certificate verification and acceptance at the intended selling venue. If its assessment cannot be substantiated, evaluate the coin independently rather than relying on the number on the label. A slab from a service not listed here does not, by itself, make a coin ungraded.

Tier and market references: “Rare Coin Grading: A Case of Market-Based Regulation” (2014), including a historical tier comparison predating CACG; Stack’s Bowers CMQ FAQs; Greysheet’s explanation of Greysheet and Bluesheet values; PCGS guarantee; NGC guarantee.

Further reading: ANACS history; ANACS services; ICG; CAC services; eBay collectible currency policy; CCCS.

The Sheldon 70-point grading scale

In 1949, Dr. William Sheldon created the Sheldon Scale, grading coins from 1 to 70 based on value. PCGS adopted this system in 1986 with encapsulated, third-party grading.[18]

The table lists the numerical grades and designations of a Sheldon Scale for circulated and Mint State coins. It is a reference to the modern scale, not a reproduction of Sheldon’s original 1949 table or PCGS’s or NGC’s own scale. 

See the PCGS Grading Standards and the NGC Coin Grading Scale.

The Sheldon 70-Point Grading Scale
Numerical grade Designation Grade name Description[13]*
70 MS-70 Mint State The "perfect coin", as minted. Has no trace of wear, handling, scratches or contact with other coins from a (5x) magnification. Coins in this grade are almost non-existent in older coins with very few examples known. Copper coins are bright with full original color and luster. Eye appeal is exceptional. However different grading  companies can make allowances like PCGS, for example, which allows minor ‘as minted’ defects at grade 70, provided they do not affect the coin’s eye appeal.[14]
69 MS-69 Mint State Coin has a sharp strike with full original luster, with no more than two small non-detracting contact marks or flaws. No hairlines or scuff marks are visible. Eye appeal is exceptional.
68 MS-68 Mint State Coin has a sharp strike with full original luster, with no more than four, lightly-scattered, contact marks or flaws. No hairlines or scuff marks show. Copper coins have lustrous original color. Eye appeal is exceptional.
67 MS-67 Mint State Coin has a sharp strike with full original luster, May have three or four very small contact marks and a single, more noticeable, but not detracting mark. On comparable coins, one or two small single hairlines may show under (6x+) magnification, or one or two partially hidden scuff marks or flaws may be present. Eye appeal is exceptional. Copper coins have lustrous original color.
66 MS-66 Mint State Coin has above average quality of strike and full original mint luster, with no more than two or three minor, but noticeable, contact marks. A few very light hairlines may show under (6x+) magnification, or there may be one or two light, scuff marks showing on frosted surfaces or in the field. The eye appeal must be above average and very pleasing for the date and originating mint. Copper coins display full original or lightly toned color.
65 MS-65 Mint State Coin shows an attractive high quality of luster and strike for the date and originating mint. A few, small, scattered, contact marks, or two larger marks may be present, and one or two small patches of hairlines may show under (5x+) magnification. Noticeable, light, scuff marks may show on the highest points of the design features. Overall quality is above average and eye appeal is very pleasing. Copper coins have full luster with original or darkened color.
64 MS-64 Mint State Coin has good, overall average luster and even strike for the type. Several small contact marks in groups, as well as one or two moderately heavy marks may be present. One or two small patches of hairlines may show under low, (3-4x) magnification. Noticeable, light, scuff marks or defects may be seen within the design or in the field. Attractive overall quality with a pleasing eye appeal. Copper coins may be slightly dull.
63 MS-63 Mint State Mint luster may be slightly impaired. Numerous small contact marks, and a few scattered, heavy marks may be seen. Small hairlines are visible without magnification. Several detracting scuff marks or defects may be present throughout the design or in the fields. The general quality is average, but overall, the coin is rather attractive. Copper pieces may be darkened or dull.
62 MS-62 Mint State Impaired or dull luster may be evident. Clusters of small marks may be present throughout with a few large marks or bag nicks in prime focal areas. Hairlines may be very noticeable. Large unattractive scuff-marks might be seen on major features. The strike, rim and planchet quality may be noticeably below average. Overall eye-appeal is generally acceptable. Copper coins will show a diminished color and tone.
61 MS-61 Mint State Mint luster may be diminished or noticeably impaired, and the surface has clusters of small contact marks throughout. Hairlines could be very noticeable. Scuff-marks may show as unattractive patches on large areas or major features. Small rim nicks, striking or planchet defects may show, and the quality may be noticeably poor. Eye appeal is unattractive. Copper pieces will be generally dull, dark and possibly spotted.
60 MS-60 Mint State Unattractive, dull or washed-out, mint luster typify this coin. There may be many large detracting contact marks (bag nicks), or damage spots, but absolutely no trace of wear. There could be a heavy concentration of hairlines (minute scratches to a coin's surface), or unattractive large areas of scuff-marks. Rim nicks may be present, and eye appeal is very poor. Copper coins may be dark, dull and spotted.
58 AU-58 About Uncirculated Almost all of the original mint luster remains
55 AU-55 About Uncirculated Three-fourths of the original mint luster remains.
53 AU-53 About Uncirculated The highest details show slight flattening and reduced lustre, with some mint lustre still present.
50 AU-50 About Uncirculated Traces of wear at the highest points of the coin. At least half of the original mint luster remains.
45 XF-45 Extremely Fine Slight, overall wear is seen at the highest points of the coin (examples being raised features). All the details are full and very sharp. Mint luster may show only in protected areas of the coin's surface (Such as between the star points).
40 XF-40 Extremely Fine Overall sharpness. Light wear seen at the highest points of the coin. Details of the coin are sharp. Traces of mint luster may show.
35 VF-35 Very Fine All lettering and major features are sharp. Light, but even wear is seen on the surface and high points of the coin. Traces of mint luster may show.
30 VF-30 Very Fine All lettering and major features are sharp. Light but even wear is seen on the surface and high points of the coin.
25 VF-25 Very Fine All lettering and major features are sharp. Light to moderate, but even wear is seen on the surface and high points of the coin.
20 VF-20 Very Fine Moderate wear on the higher surface features.
15 F-15 Fine Slightly more detail in the recessed areas of the coin.
12 F-12 Fine Some deeply recessed areas show detail. All lettering is sharp. The letters in the word LIBERTY show completely in coins with this feature, but may be weak. Moderate to considerable, but even wear throughout the coin.
10 VG-10 Very Good Slightly clearer design-features, with five or possibly six letters of the word LIBERTY showing in coins with this feature.
8 VG-8 Very Good Slight detail shows, with two to three letters of the word LIBERTY showing in coins with this feature.
6 G-6 Good Rims of the coin are complete. Peripheral lettering is full.
4 G-4 Good Rims of the coin are slightly worn, design is visible, but faint in areas, with many parts of the coin worn flat. Peripheral lettering nearly full.
3 AG-3 About Good Readable lettering although very heavily worn. The date and design may be worn smooth.
2 FR-2 Fair Some detail shows
1 PO-1 Poor Clear enough to identify, date may be worn smooth with one side of the coin blanked. Coins that are very badly corroded may also fall under this category.

*The table is a descriptive reference to the Sheldon scale. PCGS and NGC apply their own published grading standards.  PCGS describes MS/PR69 as virtually fully struck, with minuscule imperfections visible upon close inspection; NGC describes MS/PF69 as fully struck, with nearly imperceptible imperfections. Neither published definition sets the table’s limit of two small marks. At grade 70, PCGS permits minor as-minted defects that do not affect eye appeal, while NGC specifies no post-production imperfections at 5× magnification.

Reference: PCGS Grading Standards and PCGS’s current grading standards page. Descriptions are summaries, not verbatim PCGS text; the MS-70 summary reflects the current page’s allowance for minor as-minted defects.

Brilliant Uncirculated (BU), a term used in FORTYMILLION listings, describes an uncirculated coin retaining its original mint lustre. It does not mean the coin is flawless or has received a particular numerical grade. Other descriptions, such as ‘Choice Uncirculated’, ‘Gem Uncirculated’ and ‘Superb Gem Uncirculated’, are also used for different levels of Mint State preservation. Their meanings and the numerical grades associated with them can vary widely between sellers and reference sources.

Why can a Mint State coin have marks?

“Mint State” does not mean immaculate. An unworn coin can have contact marks and other imperfections that affect its grade.

The distinction is between wear and surface preservation. MS60 and MS69 both sit within Mint State, but they represent very different levels of preservation. A coin does not need to have circulated to acquire marks.

Equally, brightness alone does not establish an uncirculated condition. A shiny surface is not necessarily an uncirculated grade.

How Collector Uncirculated Coins Are Made

Uncirculated coins fall into two broad groups: business strikes made for everyday spending that remain unworn, and collector Uncirculated coins produced with additional preparation and attention to finish. Both can be uncirculated in condition, but they are made for different purposes. Mints also use Uncirculated or Brilliant Uncirculated for particular collector products or striking standards. Production methods vary between mints and issues and can affect a coin’s finish, lustre and design detail. An MS70 business strike may therefore look different from an MS70 collector Uncirculated coin, even though both have received the same numerical condition grade.

Collector Uncirculated coins can receive additional blank preparation, die treatment and handling intended to preserve their finish and detail. The U.S. Mint describes its Uncirculated coins as being made like circulating coins but with quality enhancements.[15] The Royal Mint uses Brilliant Uncirculated for a striking standard above its circulating and bullion coins, but below Proof in design definition.[16] The Royal Australian Mint describes its Uncirculated coins as being struck at a slower rate and with greater force than circulating coins, producing a sharper image with clearly defined edges. They are also slightly more polished and are typically packaged in presentation cards or sets.[17] Each mint has its own production standards for collector Uncirculated coins.

Enhanced Uncirculated and Contrasting Finishes

Enhanced Uncirculated is a collector finish that combines different surface textures across a single design. Selected areas receive frosting while others retain an uncirculated finish. This contrast draws attention to individual features and gives the design a layered appearance without changing its sculpted relief. The U.S. Mint’s 2017 Enhanced Uncirculated set combined laser-frosted areas with unpolished fields.[22]

The treatment varies by issue. PCGS describes the 2013-W Enhanced Uncirculated Silver Eagle as combining light frosting, heavy frosting and brilliant-mirrored areas. Enhanced Uncirculated therefore does not mean that every part of the coin lacks a mirrored finish. Different areas of the die receive different treatments, which transfer their textures to the metal during striking.

SP, meaning Specimen, identifies coins recognised by the grading service as specially manufactured issues, distinct from ordinary Mint State coins but not classified as Proofs. Evidence can include an unusually deliberate strike and specially prepared die surfaces; the relevant characteristics depend on the issue. SP is not awarded merely because a coin is exceptionally well preserved, nor does frosting or another special treatment automatically qualify it. It covers certain historical special strikes and modern collector issues, including the 2013-W Enhanced Uncirculated Silver Eagle, which both PCGS and NGC classify as SP. The letters identify the production category; the number following them assesses condition.

Australian Collector Finishes

Frosted Uncirculated, Royal Australian Mint. The Mint describes this finish as using the same processes and technology as its Uncirculated coins, but with a highly polished raised design against a frosted background. It gives Australian collectors a useful example of deliberate contrast between the design and the field, the flat background surrounding it. Frosted Uncirculated is the Australian product description; it should not simply be renamed Enhanced Uncirculated.

Close-up of the Australia 2019 International Year of Indigenous Languages 50 cent coin in its presentation card, showing bands of lettering and the FIFTY CENTS inscription.
Australia 2019 50 cent International Year of Indigenous Languages, Royal Australian Mint. Frosted Uncirculated finish, presented in its illustrated card.

👉 View product details and inventory options: Australia 2019 50 Cent Frosted Uncirculated International Year of Indigenous Languages Carded →

Enhanced Reverse Proof, The Perth Mint. This is a Proof finish, distinct from Enhanced Uncirculated. The Australian Wedge-tailed Eagle shown below combines an Enhanced Reverse Proof finish with ultra high relief and gilding. These terms describe separate features: the surface treatment, the height of the sculpted design and the application of gold to selected areas.

Comparing the Finishes

Comparing Coin Finishes
Coin finish Background (fields) Raised design (devices) Visual effect
Standard collector Uncirculated May be brilliant, satin or matte-like, depending on the mint and issue. Appearance depends on the die preparation and issue. Mint lustre and design detail without a prescribed arrangement of contrasting textures.
Enhanced Uncirculated Varies by issue; the U.S. Mint’s 2017 set used unpolished fields. Selected frosted areas contrast with other finishes; some issues also include brilliant-mirrored details. Multiple textures emphasise particular features within the design.
Frosted Uncirculated, Royal Australian Mint Frosted. Highly polished. A bright design stands out using frosted and polished elements.
Traditional modern Proof Commonly mirror-like. Commonly frosted. Cameo-style contrast between reflective fields and frosted designs.
Enhanced Reverse Proof Frosted in the U.S. Mint’s definition. Selected design elements receive different polished and frosted finishes. Layered contrast within the design as well as between the design and background.

The table compares typical appearances and named mint finishes, not condition grades. Exact treatments vary by issue. References: Royal Australian Mint: Commemorative coins; U.S. Mint: Coin Term Glossary; U.S. Mint: 2017 Enhanced Uncirculated set; PCGS: The Silver Eagle Shines.

Australia 2026 Wedge-tailed Eagle 5oz silver coin, showing two gilded eagle heads and a gilded rim against dark blue satin.
Australia 2026 $8 Wedge-tailed Eagle 5oz silver gilded coin, Enhanced Reverse Proof with ultra high relief. Enhanced Reverse Proof is distinct from Enhanced Uncirculated.

👉 View product details and inventory options: Australia 2026 Wedge-tailed Eagle 5oz Silver Enhanced Reverse Proof Gilded Coin →

1. Preparing the Blanks (Planchets)

  • Blank production and annealing. A blank is the metal disc before striking. Blanks can be punched from metal strip or supplied to a mint already prepared. Annealing is controlled heating that softens the metal for subsequent processing and striking; the sequence depends on the metal and production route.
  • Burnishing. The U.S. Mint describes burnishing its special Proof and Uncirculated planchets in a drum containing cleaning agents and small metal pellets. This smooths and polishes the surface before striking. It is a manufacturing treatment, not the cleaning of a finished collectible coin.
  • Upsetting. An upsetting mill raises the rim around the edge of a blank before striking. This is part of planchet preparation, not a feature exclusive to collector Uncirculated coins.

2. Preparing the Dies

  • Surface preparation. Dies transfer the design to the metal. Their surface treatment helps determine the finished coin’s appearance. The Royal Mint distinguishes its Brilliant Uncirculated striking standard from both circulating coinage and Proof; the precise polishing or texturing method depends on the issue.
  • Die condition. The condition of a die affects the detail it transfers. There is no single die-replacement interval that defines an Uncirculated collector coin across different mints, metals and designs.

The Royal Australian Mint’s 2015 gold-plated 50 cent anniversary coin illustrates how an Uncirculated collector issue can differ from an ordinary business strike. Its SUPERSTRIKE production uses specially polished dies, giving the familiar Commonwealth Coat of Arms a reflective presentation enhanced by gold plating. The distinction lies in the coin’s manufacture and finish: it remains an Uncirculated issue, not a Proof, and SUPERSTRIKE does not denote a numerical condition grade.

Reverse of the Australia 2015 gold-plated 50 cent SUPERSTRIKE, showing the Commonwealth Coat of Arms and denomination in a clear capsule.
Australia 2015 gold-plated 50 cent SUPERSTRIKE, Royal Australian Mint 50th anniversary issue. Uncirculated finish, struck using specially polished dies.

👉 View product details and inventory options: Australia 2015 Gold-Plated 50 Cent SUPERSTRIKE — Specially Polished Dies →

3. Striking and Handling

  • Striking. The U.S. Mint states that its circulating, Uncirculated and bullion coins are struck once, while Proof coins are struck at least twice. It also distinguishes faster circulating-coin presses from those used for its Uncirculated, Proof and bullion coins. Strike count, speed and pressure are mint- and issue-specific, not universal definitions of Uncirculated quality.
  • Handling. The U.S. Mint describes hand-loading its collector Uncirculated coins into the press. By contrast, its circulating coins are counted, weighed and transferred into bulk storage bags. Contact during production and handling can leave marks without creating circulation wear; special collector preparation does not guarantee a flawless surface.

Uncirculated vs. Proof Coins

The table below compares how collector Uncirculated and Proof coins are made. Production methods vary between mints and individual issues. Proof refers to how a coin is made, not its current condition: a Proof coin may show wear or damage acquired after minting.

Collector Uncirculated vs. Proof Coins
Feature Uncirculated (Collector) Proof
Number of Strikes Once in the U.S. Mint’s published process; other mints and issues can differ. At least two strikes at the U.S. Mint; The Perth Mint describes at least three strikes.
Surface Finish Can have a brilliant, satin or soft matte-like appearance, depending on the mint and issue. Traditional modern Proofs commonly combine reflective fields with frosted designs; other Proof finishes also exist.
Die Preparation Prepared to the mint’s collector striking standard; treatment varies by issue. Specially prepared dies. Polishing and selective frosting create the contrast on traditional modern Proofs.
Packaging Varies by issue; packaging does not itself establish a condition grade. The U.S. Mint describes protective capsules; presentation and packaging vary by mint and issue.

Production references: U.S. Mint: Coin Production; U.S. Mint: Products and Coin Programs; The Royal Mint: Coin Collecting Glossary; The Perth Mint: How do our numismatic coins differ from our bullion coins?.

How Proof Coins Are Made and Graded

Proof describes a special method of manufacture, not simply a polished appearance or an exceptionally well-preserved coin. Modern-day Proof coins are different from those of the past.

PCGS uses PR for Proof; NGC uses PF. A Proof coin can receive a numerical condition grade, but being a Proof does not automatically make it a 70. It can have manufacturing imperfections or suffer subsequent damage and wear.

An MS68 and a PR68 therefore describe different production categories but similar grading techniques. Proofs below PR60 or PF60 are usually referred to as impaired Proofs. As production techniques have improved, so too has the quality of the Proof coin. Higher grades are becoming more prevalent. Coin minting facilities now use precision tooling and strict handling to produce near-flawless coins routinely.

Producing a Proof involves extra preparation and closer inspection than a standard circulating coin. The Royal Australian Mint and The Perth Mint describe processes designed to sharpen detail and refine the surfaces, although their methods and striking sequences differ.

Preparing the blanks. A blank is the unstruck piece of metal that will become a coin. The Royal Australian Mint describes heating its Proof blanks to soften them, cleaning them in an acid bath, and then rotating them in a drum with tiny ball bearings to smooth surface blemishes. These processes are called annealing, pickling and burnishing respectively. They are manufacturing steps performed before striking, not cleaning treatments to try on a finished coin.

Preparing the dies. The dies are the metal tools that impress the design onto each blank. In its explanation of traditional Proof production, The Perth Mint describes selectively sandblasting the die to produce frosted design elements, then polishing the surrounding areas with diamond paste. This preparation creates the contrast between the raised design and reflective background.

Striking and inspection. Repeated strikes help the metal fill the fine recesses of the dies. The Perth Mint describes striking Proof blanks at least three times; the Royal Australian Mint describes four to six strikes, followed by individual inspection under magnification. The Perth Mint also describes inspection and encapsulation before packaging. Such care helps protect the finished surfaces, but neither the production method nor a capsule guarantees a particular certification grade.

Modern minting techniques can achieve exceptionally high standards of finish and detail, but a high grade does not necessarily make a coin rare. FORTYMILLION focuses on low-mintage coins with distinctive designs and exceptional craftsmanship. A tightly limited release offers something a high grade alone cannot: a restricted number of examples. Our emphasis is on that combination of limited production and design merit, rather than a grade in isolation.

Production sources: Royal Australian Mint: Minting process; The Perth Mint: Finishing touches make all the difference; The Perth Mint: Coins: Crafted to collect.


Classic, Pre-Decimal, Early Modern and Modern Proof Coins

Modern Proof coins differ from classic Proofs in appearance, manufacture and preservation. Although both use the same 1-to-70 grading scale, modern Proofs are assessed against expectations of near-perfection, while classic Proofs are considered in the context of historical minting limitations.

“Classic” is used here to distinguish older Proof production from modern methods, with the 1970s serving as an approximate dividing point for this comparison rather than a universal classification.

In Australia, “pre-decimal” refers to coins issued between 1910, when the first Australian coins were minted, and the introduction of decimal currency on 14 February 1966. Australian pre-decimal Proofs therefore form a specific historical group, rather than being another name for all classic Proof coins.

Proof Coin Terminology by Era

Collectors often describe older Proof coins by their monetary system or manufacturing era rather than using a catch-all label. The following terms are descriptive labels, not fixed international classifications. “Pre-decimal” identifies a monetary system; “classic”, “early modern” and “modern” describe production eras, so the groups can overlap.

  • Classic Proofs. Commonly used for nineteenth-century and early twentieth-century issues, particularly up to the mid-1930s or 1940s, when Proofs were struck manually in very small batches for dignitaries and serious collectors.
  • Pre-Decimal Proofs. Used in Australia, the UK and other Commonwealth nations for Proof coins struck before the relevant country's conversion to decimal currency, such as pre-1966 in Australia or pre-1971 in Britain.
  • Early Modern Proofs. Describes the transitional period from the 1950s through the late 1960s, when mints began scaling up Proof production for the public, using cellophane or flat-pack packaging before adopting hard acrylic capsules.
  • Modern Proofs. Generally covers issues from the 1970s onward, associated with consistent deep-Cameo finishes, high-volume collector sets and protective packaging that often includes capsules.

Why Terminology Matters in Coin Collecting

Era-specific labels help collectors and graders communicate expectations about how a coin was made and preserved.

  • Packaging expectations. Older Proof coins were often stored in tissue paper or presentation cases, leaving their surfaces exposed to the material they lay in, as well as dust, moisture and other impurities in the surrounding environment. Many modern Proofs are supplied in protective capsules, reducing direct contact with presentation materials. Packaging and storage history therefore provide context, but do not determine a coin’s condition by themselves.
  • Die preparation context. Grouping coins as “pre-decimal” or “classic” provides context for frosted Cameo contrast as a bonus of early die strikes rather than a guaranteed production standard.

How Modern Proofs Differ from Classic Proofs

Advances in metallurgy, die preparation and handling have changed the appearance of Proof coins and how their surfaces age.

Classic vs. Modern Proof Coins
Feature Classic Proofs (pre-1970s) Modern Proofs (1970s–present)
Surface contrast Often have uniformly mirrored surfaces. Strong frosted Cameo contrast was less common and usually appeared on early strikes. Modern techniques can produce strong frosted contrast against reflective fields; appearance varies by mint, issue and Proof finish.[21]
Die life and consistency Frosting can diminish as dies are repeatedly used, reducing contrast on later strikes. Modern Proof-die preparation can combine laser frosting with protective coatings. At the U.S. Mint’s San Francisco facility, prepared Proof dies receive a thin chrome coating to protect the design during striking.[21]
Handling and packaging Frequently stored in tissue paper or presentation cases, leaving the surfaces exposed to the material they lay in and to dust, moisture and other impurities in the surrounding environment. Modern Proofs are commonly supplied in protective capsules. The Perth Mint describes hand-placing its precious-metal coins, with a few exceptions, into acrylic capsules after testing.[20]
Finish varieties Primarily traditional brilliant Proofs, with some matte finishes. A broader range of presentations, including reverse Proof and enhanced reverse Proof finishes. High relief, selective plating and colourisation may also be used on particular issues. Enhanced Uncirculated is a separate collector Uncirculated finish, not a Proof variety.[22]

Background reading: Wikipedia contributors, “Proof coinage” and “Cameo (coinage)”. This comparison is an editorial summary, not a table reproduced from Wikipedia.

These links take you to Wikipedia.

Differences in Grading Considerations

PCGS and NGC use the same core numerical scale for Proof coins, but practical expectations and the significance of particular designations differ between eras.

Stricter tolerance for modern flaws. Modern mints routinely produce coins of exceptional quality. Small milk spots, lint marks or faint hairlines can therefore attract greater scrutiny on modern Proofs than comparable imperfections on nineteenth-century examples.

Eye appeal and toning. Older Proof coins were often stored in tissue paper or presentation cases, leaving their surfaces exposed to the material they lay in, as well as dust, moisture and other impurities in the surrounding environment. Many modern Proofs are supplied in protective capsules, reducing that direct contact. This different storage history helps explain expectations about their appearance. Natural, attractive toning is not automatically damage on either older or modern Proofs; its nature, severity and effect on the surfaces matter. Haze, spotting and harmful surface changes must be assessed separately.[23]

Cameo designations. Cameo (CAM) and Deep or Ultra Cameo (DCAM/UC) designations apply to both eras. On classic Proofs, strong contrast can be a significant rarity and command a substantial premium. On modern Proofs, it is generally expected.

Strike sharpness. Historic Proofs can show uneven metal flow or evidence of die fatigue, so strike quality is considered against what was typical for the particular date and mint. Modern Proofs are expected to display a fully struck, sharply defined design.

Cameo, Deep Cameo and Ultra Cameo

These terms describe contrast between the raised design elements and the surrounding background, known as the fields.

On qualifying Proof coins, frosted design elements contrast with reflective fields. Cameo identifies qualifying contrast; stronger contrast can receive Deep Cameo at PCGS or Ultra Cameo at NGC. Each service applies its own criteria.

The designation adds information about appearance. It does not replace the condition grade. PR69 DCAM, for example, combines a Proof designation, a numerical grade and a Deep Cameo designation.

Australia 1978 two cent proof in its PCGS slab, showing Queen Elizabeth II against reflective fields and the PR68 DCAM certification label.
Australia 1978 frill-necked lizard 2 cent proof, certified PCGS PR68 DCAM. The obverse is shown: PR68 records the Proof coin’s condition grade; DCAM identifies its Deep Cameo contrast.

👉 View product details and inventory options: Australia 1978 Frill-Necked Lizard 2 Cent Proof PCGS PR68 DCAM →

What does “Details” mean?

A coin may retain considerable design detail while having a surface problem that prevents a normal numerical grade. Improper cleaning, scratches and other damage can lead to a Details assessment.

“AU Details — Improperly Cleaned” communicates two things: the approximate level of remaining detail and a significant surface qualification. It should not be treated as an ordinary AU numerical grade.

The qualification matters. Read the complete description, rather than stopping at the condition term.

Does 70 mean perfect?

NGC defines a Mint State or Proof 70 coin as having no post-production imperfections at 5× magnification.

PCGS defines MS/PR-70 as: “Fully struck and lustrous, free of visual marks. The PCGS 70 grading standard does allow for ‘as minted’ defects, as long as those flaws are minor and do not impact the eye appeal of the coin.”[14]

That is a defined examination standard, not an unlimited statement of perfection under every possible magnification or lighting condition. Precision matters more than the casual use of “perfect”.

Palau 2020 Gilded Fortune gold-plated silver four-leaf clover coin in its PCGS slab, showing the ornamental leaf design and MS70 First Day of Issue label.
Palau 2020 $5 Gilded Fortune Four-Leaf Clover 1 oz silver coin, certified PCGS MS70. The label records the Mint State condition grade separately from its First Day of Issue designation.

👉 View product details and inventory options: Palau 2020 $5 Gilded Fortune Four-Leaf Clover 1 oz Silver PCGS MS70 →

Both sides of the Niue 2023 Azure Kingfisher silver proof coin in its PCGS slab, showing the coloured kingfisher, Public Seal of Niue and PR70DCAM label, certification 48414282.
Niue 2023 $1 Azure Kingfisher 1 oz silver Proof coin, certified PCGS PR70 DCAM. PR70 records the Proof condition grade; DCAM identifies its Deep Cameo contrast. Both sides of the slab are shown.

👉 View product details and inventory options: Niue 2023 $1 Azure Kingfisher 1 oz Silver Proof PCGS PR70 DCAM →

Canada 2016 $20 Venetian Glass Snail silver Proof coin in an NGC slab, showing the glass snail, green leaf and PF70 Ultra Cameo label.
Canada 2016 $20 Venetian Glass Snail silver Proof coin, certified NGC PF70 Ultra Cameo. PF70 records the Proof condition grade; Ultra Cameo identifies its contrast. The label also carries the separate Early Releases designation.

👉 View product details and inventory options: Canada 2016 $20 Venetian Glass Snail Silver Proof NGC PF70 Ultra Cameo →

What a grade does not tell you

A coin’s grade does not tell you how rare it is, how historically important it is, or what it might be worth in the future.

Two coins with the same grade may differ in toning, visual character and appeal. A lower-graded coin may be scarcer than a higher-graded coin of another issue. The grade describes one important aspect of the coin, not its entire significance.

Reading beyond the number

Begin with the coin’s identity: country of issue, date, denomination and variety. Establish which mint produced it, as the country of issue is not always where the coin was struck. Read the certification label for the coin’s numerical grade, any production designation such as MS, PR or PF, and any additional designations or qualifications. Use that information alongside your research and a close examination of the coin’s detail and surfaces.

The Australian 1981 20 cent coin illustrates why identifying the mint and variety matters before interpreting the grade. It was struck at three different mints, with distinctive features that should not be mistaken for wear or a weak strike.

In 1981, industrial action at the Royal Australian Mint in Canberra led to some Australian coin production being outsourced to the Royal Mint in Llantrisant, Wales, and the Royal Canadian Mint in Winnipeg, Canada.

The Canadian-struck example shown below is known as ‘Wavy Legends’ or ‘Scalloped Letters’ for the curved bases of letters around the Queen’s portrait, and ‘3½ Claw’ for the shortened claw on the platypus reverse. Canberra- and Welsh-struck examples have four full claws. Its PCGS label identifies the variety and records an MS64 condition grade. The variety identifies features present when the coin was struck; the grade assesses its state of preservation.

How Mint Differences Affect Grading

The mint and variety must be identified before differences in the design are interpreted as wear. The Winnipeg-struck 1981 20 cent has flat obverse fields, indented bases to some letters and a shortened inner claw. Welsh-struck coins appear to copy the Canberra design more closely. Similarity of design does not, by itself, establish that the mints used the same physical tooling. The distinguishing features identify the variety; they are not a condition grade.

How the Different Strike Looks Affect Grading

  • The “Half Claw”. On the Winnipeg issue, the shortened claw nearest the platypus’s body is a recognised identifying feature, not evidence that the coin has lost that detail through circulation wear.
  • Fields and lettering. The Canadian issue’s flat obverse fields and indented letter bases help distinguish its design. These features should not be confused with damage acquired after striking.
  • Contact marks and bagging. The cited reference records that the overseas-struck coins were sent to Australia in mint bags and distributed through banks. Contact in bags and rolls can leave marks without circulation wear. That distribution history alone does not establish how much scarcer Gem-grade Canadian examples are than Canberra examples.
  • Wear versus incomplete detail. The cited reference warns that a weakly struck Canberra or Welsh coin can appear to have a shortened claw. Tilting the coin may reveal the remaining claw detail. Identification should therefore use the obverse features as well as the reverse, rather than relying on the apparent claw length alone.

3½ Claw Identification Features by Mint

1981 Australian 20 Cent — Identification Features by Mint
Feature Canberra (RAM) Winnipeg (Canada) Llantrisant (Wales)
Platypus Claws 4 full claws; weak striking can obscure part of the inner claw. 3 full claws and a shortened inner claw (“3½ Claw”). 4 full claws; weak striking can obscure part of the inner claw.
Obverse Lettering Compare with the Canadian issue’s distinctive indented letter bases. Indented or scalloped bases to some letters, used with the reverse claw feature for identification. Design appears to follow Canberra’s more closely; do not identify the mint from apparent claw length alone.
Obverse Fields No comparative lustre or rim-profile claim is made here. Flat fields are a documented identifying feature, not a numerical grade. No comparative lustre or rim-profile claim is made here.

Variety and distribution references: Independent Coin News, July 2023 and October 2025. These references support the identifying features described above, not a comparative population or Gem-scarcity ranking. Grading reference: PCGS: A Quick Reference Guide to Grading Mint State Coins.

1981 Australian 20 cent coin in its PCGS slab, with a label identifying Wavy Legends 3½ Claw and the MS64 grade above the Queen Elizabeth II obverse.
Australia 1981 20 cent Wavy Legends 3½ Claw, minted in Canada and certified PCGS MS64. The slab label records the variety and condition grade separately.

👉 View product details and inventory options: Australia 1981 20 Cent Wavy Legends 3½ Claw PCGS MS64 →

Australian Coin Reference Books

Renniks Australian Coin & Banknote Values, 33rd edition, edited by Michael Pitt (2025). A broad reference for Australian coins and banknotes, including issue information, mintages and indicative valuations. This edition contains approximately 4,900 colour images and covers pre-decimal and decimal currency, collector releases and Australia Post numismatic covers. Catalogue values are a reference point, not a guaranteed selling price.

Pirate Guide to Collecting Australian Coins, 2025–2026 edition, by Damian Walker. An illustrated guide to Australian decimal circulation coins, organised by denomination. It includes commemorative designs, mintmarks, privy marks, portrait changes, selected errors and varieties, and published mintage information.

Renniks Australian Pre-Decimal & Decimal Coin Errors, by Ian McConnelly. A specialist introduction to Australian minting errors, covering coins from 1911 onward. It explains error types and terminology, with a glossary and rarity assessments.

Renniks Australian Pre-Decimal Coin Varieties, 3rd edition, by Ian McConnelly. A reference for identifying pre-decimal varieties, including doubling, die cracks, cuds, overdates and mintmark differences. Listed varieties receive rarity classifications from Common to Extremely Rare; the book does not provide valuations.

Footnotes

[1] Ken Bressett and A. Kosoff. Official A.N.A. Grading Standards for United States Coins, Fifth Edition. American Numismatic Association. p. 34.

[2] Steve Roach (July 19, 2018). “Heavy adjustment marks can shave market value”. Coin World. Archived September 4, 2020. Retrieved December 31, 2022.

[3] Steve Roach (August 13, 2019). “Market Analysis: When a planchet defect is not unusual”. Coin World. Archived November 27, 2021. Retrieved May 16, 2023.

[4] Mike Sherman (April 19, 2016). “Difficult to Grade Coins – Part Three”. Professional Coin Grading Service. Archived September 13, 2021. Retrieved October 19, 2017.

[5] Mike Sherman. “Toning. Does it help, or hurt the value of a coin?”. Professional Coin Grading Service. Archived November 11, 2020. Retrieved October 19, 2017.

[6] “Grades multiplied over years”. Numismatic News. October 16, 2017. Archived December 2, 2022. Retrieved October 19, 2017.

[7] “Insidious Fingerprints”. Numismatic Guaranty Company. March 17, 2008. Archived July 31, 2021. Retrieved December 31, 2022.

[8] “PVC Damage on World Coins – What It Is & How to Avoid It”. CoinWeek. October 24, 2016. Archived June 28, 2017. Retrieved October 19, 2017.

[9] “NUMISMATICS' GREATEST MISNOMER: CARBON SPOTS”. www.coinbooks.org. April 18, 2014. Archived December 2, 2022. Retrieved October 19, 2017.

[10] “Glossary of Coin Terms”. Heritage Auctions. Archived November 16, 2022. Retrieved May 16, 2023.

[11] Thomas E. Hudgeons, Jr. (11 June 2013). The Official Blackbook Price Guide to United States Coins 2014, 52nd Edition. Diversified Publishing. ISBN 9780375723490. Retrieved August 25, 2017.

[12] “Counterfeit Detection: Take a Look at Whizzed Coins”. CoinWeek. December 21, 2022. Archived May 16, 2023. Retrieved May 16, 2023.

[13] “How United States Coins are Graded”. pcgs.com. Archived from the original on January 21, 2022. Retrieved 2013-06-16.

[14] Professional Coin Grading Service. “PCGS Grading Standards”, MS/PR-70 definition. Accessed 13 November 2026.

[15] U.S. Mint. “Products and Coin Programs”, description of Uncirculated coins.

[16] The Royal Mint. “Coin Collecting Glossary”, Brilliant Uncirculated striking standard.

[17] Royal Australian Mint. “Commemorative coins”, Uncirculated section: striking rate, force, finish and presentation-card packaging.

[18] Historical summary adapted from PCGS Grading Standards, using 1949, the publication year of Early American Cents. This is a paraphrase, not a direct quotation.

[19] William H. Sheldon. Early American Cents, 1793–1814: An Exercise in Descriptive Classification with Tables of Rarity and Value. First edition. New York: Harper & Brothers, 1949. Library catalogue record.

[20] The Perth Mint, “Insiders’ guide to coin production”, describes hand-placing its precious-metal coins, with a few exceptions, into acrylic capsules after testing. The U.S. Mint’s “Products and Coin Programs” confirms protective capsules for its Proof coins. These sources support protective encapsulation, not a universal claim that every modern Proof is immediately or hermetically sealed.

[21] U.S. Mint, “Die Making”, documents laser frosting and a thin chrome coating applied to prepared Proof dies through physical vapour deposition at San Francisco. The coating protects the design during striking; the source does not specify how many Proof strikes retain the frosting. NGC’s “Proof, Proof Cameo and Proof Ultra Cameo” explains how contrast can fade as dies are used.

[22] U.S. Mint, “Coin Term Glossary”, distinguishes Enhanced Uncirculated from Enhanced Reverse Proof. Its 2017 Enhanced Uncirculated set announcement describes laser-frosted areas and unpolished fields, explicitly distinguishing their contrast from Proof’s mirror-like finish.

[23] PCGS, “Originality and Toning”, discusses original, natural-looking toning versus unnatural or unattractive colour. NGC’s “Conservation of Modern Coins” describes spotting, haze and other contamination on modern coins, including coins in original mint packaging. Protective packaging reduces handling and direct contact but does not guarantee unchanged surfaces.

Sources and further reading

Previous Next